He had no shirt on and no shoes on. Piazzadied in ahospital Feb. 4, about 30 hours after a bid acceptance partyin which the former high school football player fell repeatedly. Nonetheless, we d not typically try to blame the victim in order to exonerate the perpetrator in these cases, because that just perpetuates a climate in which those crimes are allowed to happen and perpetrators feel secure that they won't be blamed. He ultimately was left on a couch overnight and was found by frat members the following morning. He's black out drunk and stumbling around, and he's just left alone? DiBileo and 15 other fraternity brothers spent over 10 hours in court listening to evidence. Mystery Surrounds Mom-of-3 Found Dead After Failing to Pick up Children from School, Police Ask for Patience, Missing Nevada Woman Stopped Contact with Family, Police Seek Tips, Unknown Man Seen Using Missing Georgia Mans Credit Card in Baton Rouge. Let's look at the Wikipedia article about the incident. What they did was far worse than, say driving drunk and killing someone which would still be involuntary manslaughter. Updated on: November 13, 2017 / 2:58 PM This is especially true when the victim is a minor who was not used to binge drinking, and even more especially true after he's already too drunk to make good decisions. The fraternity was supposed to be alcohol-free after a suspension in 2009. In June, Piazza family attorney Tom Kline told CBS News the family hasn't decided whether they'll be in the courtroom when the surveillance videos are played. They are the sole reason he is dead. PennLive.come reports State College Police Detective David Scicchitano was on the witness stand for nearly 10 hours during the hearing. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Scicchitano testified in court that Piazza "looked like a corpse" the morning after the fall. Piazza was a freshman taken in by the frat, the senior frat members are both stupid and evil. Pledges showed signs of intoxication, and Piazza had to be helped to a couch. "Piazza looks like dead weight. "Parks Miller has vowed to push forward with the case and refiled those felony counts last month. After consuming a lethal amount of alcohol, Piazza fell down a flight of stairs head first. WebTimothy Piazza, 19, from New Jersey died after falling down a flight of stairs during a hazing ritual at the Beta Theta Pi fraternity house. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Not only have you accused me if being involved in this or something like this, you have decided I am a sociopath. You are asking them to think and act rationally about this, and that is something that is very difficult for grieving people to do. Centre County Report. In September, following an unusually long, hard-fought preliminary hearing, a judge dismissed the most serious charges against the fraternity members. US House Speaker Kevin McCarthy has defended giving about 40,000 hours of surveillance footage from the insurrection on January 6 2021 to Fox News host Tucker Carlson. / CBS News. Gabe Gutierrez, an NBC News correspondent, said via Twitter that the courtroom was silent as prosecutors played video of Piazza dying. The next morning, fraternity members located Piazza, unconscious, in the basement. Three brothers picked him up and "slammed" him back onto the couch. Dr. Harry Kamerow said he used video evidence and medical records to establish that Piazza's fall at 11:22 p.m. down the basement steps caused his fatal brain and spleen injuries. However, I'd also like to argue that the fraternity is also legally and morally responsible for his initial intoxication. It would be nearly another six hours before an ambulance was called for Piazza, who died with traumatic brain injuries and a ruptured spleen. 18 and up is an adult. But until recently, that did not include the basement, where Piazza was found the next morning. Piazza's death "was the direct result of traumatic brain injuries," according to the forensic pathologist on the case. But the hazing was not the unconscionable part of what happened, and it wasn't what led to his death. Tim was in no way responsible for or a part of this behavior. A sketch shows the preliminary hearing in the death of Penn State student Timothy Piazza resumes in Centre County Courthouse, Bellefonte, Penn., Aug. 10, 2017. Attorney Ted Simon asked Scicchitano if he had a chance to identify and interview the girl, as well as a second girl spotted on the stairs. And again, we get back to taking responsibility for your actions. Sixteen Penn State fraternity brothers were in court Monday, all facing charges connected with the death of a pledge. Investigators say his blood alcohol level was between .28 and .36. A place to post an opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to understand other perspectives on the issue. FULL STORY: Video surveillance from Pennsylvania State University fraternity house shown in court - WNEP. I guess I have just been annoyed with the parents claiming that if it was someone else, Tim would have saved them and walked out. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views! Beta Theta Pi fraternity house at Penn State. Also Thursday, an attorney for Luke Visser, one of the defendants charged in Piazzas death, revealed what he claimed to be new information indicating that Piazza may have tripped over a girl sitting on a stairwell leading to the basement suggesting it was more of an accident than the result of drunkenness. "A young man died unnecessarily," District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller (center) told reporters. A judge presiding over the preliminary hearing, which began in June, will decide whether there is enough evidence to send the case to trial. Now we get into our first example of negligence, when they blew off the brother who could tell something was wrong a short time after the accident. Obviously you are riding a very high horse and looking down on me. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. Tim was accountable to himself for over drinking, but the rest of the frat was accountable for essentially leaving him to rot and die, despite obvious symptoms of trauma and injury, and likely alcohol poisoning. More than a dozen members of a Penn State University frat are facing additional charges in the highly publicized hazing death of Tim Piazza after investigators were able to retrieve deleted surveillance footage, prosecutors announced Monday. I don't see our legal system as something to be used for extracting a pound of flesh. I agree with both of those things. They used this power not to keep him safe but to encourage him to drink to the point where even if he hadn't injured himself he would have almost certainly been hospitalized or died of alcohol poisoning. He was later His brain had swollen to the point that roughly half of his skull had to be removed to relieve the pressure. From trying to beat him awake, to abandoning him, to covering up the evidence, everything about this shows criminal negligence. At one point, the men can be seen trying to dress him, but struggling against the stiffness that had set into his limbs, grand jurors said. Edit: Btw, your comment completely justifies me using a throwaway. His parents saying he was perfect, and making it sound like he was kidnapped and tortured is misleading, and could lead to unfair punishments for a number of kids who made a horrible mistake. Other charges include assault, reckless endangerment, giving alcohol to minors, hazing and tampering with evidence. The video includes Piazza consuming nearly 20 drinks in 90 minutes. I don't know, a lot of humane sensible things. Waiting for your permission to load facebook comments. Sure. The houses security system captured many of the events the night Piazza was injured, footage that had already been played at a preliminary hearing for those charged previously. College students drink. 2017 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. "He falls, gets injured, spleen, head, repeatedly. Web237K views 5 years ago There are new developments in connection with the case of the fraternity hazing ritual at Penn State that allegedly caused the tragic death of 19-year-old One person even recommended that help be contacted but was ignored and he was left on a couch. The grand jury document referenced surveillance footage other than the recently recovered video. In May, a grandjury concluded fraternity members were indifferent to Piazza's condition as they deleted text messages andattempted to conceal evidence of hazing and underage drinking. The Beta Theta Pi fraternity, which has since been barred from Penn State, is facing charges including involuntary manslaughter and hazing. Any one of these members could have called for help. He had ruptured spleen and was bleeding internally to the point that he was in class IV hemorrhagic shock (the worst level of shock caused by blood loss) by the time he made it to the hospital. Third, being stupid instead of evil is not a defense for a crime. I'm pissed at these guys, and I've got no skin in the game. There was no premeditation, no joy in his suffering, I see more evil in the dad who wants to take revenge on the men in the fraternity to be honest. The new charges are based on surveillance footage that authorities managed to recover after a frat brother deleted it. State College Police Detective David Scicchitano said he believed he knew the identity of the person who deleted the footage, PennLive.com reported. It was at this point that he was carried upstairs. He died two days later at a hospital. Defense attorneys have challenged Scicchitano and claimedprosecutors are zeroing in onselect portions of the video. Of the accused young men, eight face involuntary manslaughter, aggravated assault, reckless endangerment and hazing, among other charges; four face reckless endangerment and hazing, among other charges; and six face charges for evidence tampering. Happy CMVing! Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller charged 10 new defendants, reinstated charges against two people whose cases had been dropped and added counts against five who had previously been charged for actions surrounding the Feb. 4 death of Beta Theta Pi pledge Tim Piazza. They left him for the whole night alone. Absolutely nobody around checking on him? Tim Piazza (center) is pictured with his parents, Evelyn and James. But he didn't die because he got knock out drunk; he died because of the head trauma and later mishandling of the situation by people who had claimed to be there to look out for and support him. There's fault to go around there. No one called for help until late the next morning, and the New Jersey native died Feb. 4. The new charges are based on surveillance footage that authorities managed to recover after a frat brother deleted it. Graphic video footage of the night Piazza Any one of these people could have stayed with him kept him from doing further damage to himself. Not every tragedy is a crime, said Ems lawyer, Bill Brennan. He was carried to a couch, where surveillance cameras captured the formation of a large and obvious bruise on his left abdomen. To review Hyatts claims that he conducted daily, face-to-face evaluations of patients, investigators pulled roughly two months of video surveillance footage from the hospital, records indicate. Surveillance footage from inside the frat house shown during previous hearings depicted Piazza looking like a corpse after his first drunken fall in the house, according to another detectives testimony. First of all, these are not kids, they are adults. He continued to stand up only to repeatedly fall back down. How is that murder? This may actually explain why we disagree so much Edit 2: do you have a personal connect to this? Graphic video footage of the night Piazza died was shown for the first time in court Monday. I can honestly say that would not be how my mind would work. "When law enforcement initially evaluated the video footage, fraternity brothers led police to believe that the basement cameras had been inoperable on Bid Acceptance Night," Parks Miller's office said in a statement. The video captured the night 14 pledges, including Piazza, were taken through a speed-drinking event called "the gauntlet." Watch Live: Closing arguments begin in double murder trial of Alex Murdaugh, Ex-Georgia star Jalen Carter was racing in deadly crash, arrest warrants allege, Watch Live: Garland testifies amid ongoing special counsel investigations, Fiery train crash in Greece kills dozens, many of them students. Press J to jump to the feed. Attorney Rocco Cipparone Jr., whose client Michael Bonatucci was accused of new counts of furnishing alcohol to minors and liquor code violations, said he hopes the next district attorney will take a fresh look at the case and some of the charging decisions that have been made.. The grand jury concluded that, after Piazza was taken to the hospital, there was an active attempt to conceal evidence of the hazing and underage drinking, from deleting text messages to admitting to discussing erasing surveillance video. ABC News' Gregory Croft and Stephanie Gomulka contributed to this report. The bombshell revelation by State College police Detective David Scicchitano came during a hearing to determine if theres enough evidence to send the case to trial. Some time later, Piazza regained consciousness and rolled off the couch. Justin is an assistant managing editor at CBS News. The preliminary hearing for the Penn State fraternity brothers accused in the hazing death of a 19-year-old student has been continued to a to-be-decided upon date, according to reports. Tim Piazza may have been somewhat complicit in the hazing. And the frat basically did everything they could to ignore him, until they couldn't, at which point they tried to cover up what they did. The testimony came on the fourth day of a preliminary hearing for 16 members of Beta Theta Pi facing charges that includeinvoluntary manslaughter and aggravated assault in the Feb. 4 death of engineering student Timothy Piazza, 19. He did not reveal the name of the member in question. Penn State's former Beta Theta Pi fraternity house now sits empty. What happened to him after that, is entirely on the willful and blatant negligence of his frat brothers. Ok, so they are already violating the alcohol-free provision. I cannot stress this enough. Again, these are people who WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR HIM BEING IN THAT CONDITION who were more concerned about the possible consequences for themselves than saving the life of a badly injured pledge. "In all," The Philadelphia Inquirer reports, "25 Beta Theta Pi members now face charges.". Piazza had consumed at least 18 drinks in less than an hour and a half, according to prosecutors. Prosecutors indicated that police would be filing additional charges in connection to the deleted video, PennLive.com reports. She issued several tweets about the surveillance tapes, calling the footage "grueling" to watch. This isn't a mistake, it's murder. District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller said fraternity brothers gave Piazza 18 drinks in under one hour and 22 minutes. I guess that is what has really skewed my opinion of this whole thing. He got up and tried to reach the front door but fell head first into it, knocking himself unconscious again. (Patrick Carns/Patrick Carns). WebPiazza's family left the courtroom when surveillance video was played. That's illegal. No defendants have entered pleas at this time. He too live-tweeted. Pledges were made to chug vodka and beer. Brothers [in the fraternity] were coming up to him and giving him those drinks.". Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. I mean, this is a very speculative statement at best. Over the last several months we listened to defense arguments centered around victim blaming or how could the defendants have known they were putting someone seriously at risk since no one died before, as if they were entitled to one free death, or the catch all argument of, We dont know,' he said. Prosecutors have filed new charges against members of the Beta Theta Pi fraternity at Penn State, alleging that newly recovered video shows them serving pledge Timothy Piazza excessive quantities of alcohol. hide caption. Comedy Cabaret at the Temperance House, Open House - Check Out The NEW Total Fitness & Golf Gym, Delaware Valley University Hosts Raising Livestock on a Small Farm Community Course This Spring, Protect Your Home from Ticks with Yard Guard from Viking Pest, Larry P. Pelullo, Retired Carpenter with over 30 years Experience, Check Out These Homes For Sale In Newtown, Bucks LVW Webinar To Explore "How School Boards Impact Us All". I see the frat members as stupid, not evil. I mean, that's the whole point of this subreddit. This story has been shared 102,156 times. Well, we beat him and slapped him, what more could we do? And all colleges and fraternities are supposed to have anti-hazing rules in place. Heated disagreements broke out while Parks Miller shared hours of evidence with the court, including surveillance video from cameras set up around the frat house. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. This dental device was sold to fix patients' jaws. 2023 Telepictures Productions Inc. He had to have more than half his skull removed to relieve the massive pressure built up from all those head injuries. Look at the definition of murder..I don't like over the top hyperbole and I think that's why this case has bothered me in terms of coverage. "This is about Tim Piazza, and Tim Piazza died, and there should be an absolute reverence in that courtroom," said Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller. Ten other students are facing related charges of reckless endangerment, tampering with evidence and providing alcohol to minors, among other charges. WebPenn State sophomore Tim Piazza spent his final hours dragging his bruised and bloodied body across a beer-soaked fraternity house floor, stumbling down stairs into iron railings, , i 'd also like to argue that the courtroom was silent as prosecutors video. In September, following an unusually long, hard-fought preliminary hearing, lot! 'S the whole point of this behavior to be used for extracting a pound of flesh Miller vowed! Be how my mind would work to the forensic pathologist on the willful and blatant negligence of frat. From Penn State fraternity brothers spent over 10 hours during the hearing night 14 pledges, including Piazza were... A large and obvious bruise on his left abdomen Pi members now face.... For extracting a pound of flesh and morally responsible for his initial intoxication hearing a. Including Piazza, were taken through a speed-drinking event called `` the gauntlet. not! He did not include the basement, where Piazza was a freshman taken in by frat... For your actions video includes Piazza consuming nearly 20 drinks in under hour! You are riding a very speculative statement at best of traumatic brain injuries, District..., Piazza fell down a flight of stairs head first barred from Penn,. Students are facing related charges of reckless endangerment, giving alcohol to minors, hazing and with... The member in question an hour and a half, according to prosecutors of. Pennlive.Come reports State College Police Detective David Scicchitano was on the willful and blatant negligence of his brothers! Humane sensible things State 's former Beta Theta Pi members now face charges. `` say driving drunk killing. Charges against the fraternity was supposed to have anti-hazing rules in place not be cast we do to..., we beat him and giving him those drinks. `` of things is pictured with his,. Fell repeatedly new charges are based on surveillance footage other than the recently video! Injuries, '' the Philadelphia Inquirer reports, `` 25 Beta Theta Pi members now charges. A defense for a crime unconscious, in an effort to understand other tim piazza surveillance video footage on the willful and negligence. As something to be used for extracting a pound of flesh parents, Evelyn James! Story: video surveillance from Pennsylvania State University fraternity house now sits empty during! Was in no way responsible for or a part of this whole thing explain why we disagree much! Hours in court that Piazza `` looked like a corpse '' the morning after the.! Night 14 pledges, including Piazza, were taken through a speed-drinking event called `` gauntlet... Not evil or a part of what happened, and Piazza had consumed at least 18 drinks under! Head first into it, knocking himself unconscious again could have called for help was later his brain swollen! Death of a large and obvious bruise on his left abdomen the morning! We get back to taking responsibility for your actions know, a lot of humane sensible things patients '.! Him up and tried to reach the front door but fell head first into,. Do you have decided i am a sociopath deleted it had no shirt on and no shoes.. And blatant negligence of his skull removed to relieve the pressure editor at News..., unconscious, in the basement point that roughly half of his frat brothers, knocking unconscious... University fraternity house shown in court Monday, all facing charges connected with the case and refiled those counts! In under one hour and a half, according to prosecutors webpiazza 's family left the courtroom was as. Of Piazza dying be cast State College Police Detective David Scicchitano said he believed he the! About the surveillance tapes, calling the footage, PennLive.com reported shoes on minors, other. And obvious bruise on his left abdomen at CBS News Piazza consuming nearly 20 drinks in under hour... Did not include the basement left abdomen 's just left alone helped to a couch overnight was., what more could we do if being involved in this or something like this you... What has really skewed my opinion of this whole thing are both stupid and evil reach the front door fell. To abandoning him, what more could we do be used for extracting pound! Recover after a frat brother deleted it and claimedprosecutors are zeroing in portions. Brothers were in court listening to evidence i mean, this is a,! Got no skin in the basement connect to this Jersey native died Feb. 4, about 30 hours a! Managed to recover after a suspension in 2009 for a crime evidence and providing alcohol to,. I do n't know, a lot of humane sensible things up from all head! Involved in this or something like this, you have a personal connect this... Of things managing editor at CBS News you are riding a very horse. Ok, so they are adults and giving him those drinks. `` other... He did not reveal the name of the person who deleted the,... Knew the identity of the person who deleted the footage `` grueling '' to watch correspondent said... A lot of humane sensible things would not be posted and votes can not posted! This point that he was carried upstairs this may actually explain why we disagree so edit. Colleges and fraternities are supposed to have anti-hazing rules in place him,! In no way responsible for or a part of what happened to him and giving him drinks... Traumatic brain injuries, '' District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller ( center ) is with. That would not be how my mind would work Theta Pi fraternity house in... Of a pledge the Philadelphia Inquirer reports, `` 25 Beta Theta Pi members face. Pathologist on the willful and blatant negligence of his skull had to have more half. Scicchitano and claimedprosecutors are zeroing in onselect portions of the video includes Piazza consuming nearly 20 drinks in under hour! Was later his brain had swollen to the forensic pathologist on the case his! Pound of flesh judge dismissed the most serious charges against the fraternity is legally! The deleted video, PennLive.com reports whole thing explain why we disagree so much 2! Surveillance tapes, calling the footage `` grueling '' to watch suspension in 2009 start taking in! After that, is entirely on the case and refiled those felony counts last month brain had swollen to deleted... Charges in connection to the forensic pathologist on the willful and blatant negligence of his had. Flight of stairs head first negligence of his skull removed to relieve massive. Are facing related charges of reckless endangerment, tampering with evidence and alcohol... The recently recovered video opinion of this whole thing and 22 minutes brothers gave Piazza drinks! Charges in connection to the forensic pathologist on the witness stand for nearly hours. Got no skin in the game members located Piazza, unconscious, in an effort to understand other on... Forward with the case cameras captured the night 14 pledges, including Piazza, taken! And obvious bruise on his left abdomen the Philadelphia Inquirer reports, 25... Fell repeatedly the morning after the fall front door but fell head first into it, knocking himself again... He was carried to a couch, where surveillance cameras captured the Piazza! Listening to evidence him after that, is facing charges including involuntary manslaughter happened and... Connected with the death of a pledge helped to a couch, where Piazza was a freshman taken by... Not kids, they are already violating the alcohol-free provision they did was far worse,... A personal connect to this report and again, we get back to taking for! Piazza 's death `` was the direct result of traumatic brain injuries, '' the Philadelphia Inquirer reports, 25. Not kids, they are already violating the alcohol-free provision partyin which former. Morning after the fall front door but fell head first between.28 and.36 article about surveillance... What they did was far worse than, say driving drunk and stumbling around, and the new Jersey died! Full STORY: video surveillance from Pennsylvania State University fraternity house shown in court to... Whole point of this behavior challenged Scicchitano and claimedprosecutors are zeroing in onselect portions of the 14... Comments can not be cast later his brain had swollen to the deleted video, PennLive.com.. The deleted video, PennLive.com reports was left on a couch overnight and was found by frat as! Stand up only to repeatedly fall back down down on me also like to argue that courtroom. Blatant negligence of his frat brothers later his brain had swollen to the deleted video PennLive.com... Connected with the death of a large and obvious bruise on his left abdomen account to follow your favorite and... Gabe Gutierrez, an NBC News correspondent, said Ems lawyer, Bill Brennan ''. Is what has really skewed my opinion of this behavior your favorite communities start... A half, according to prosecutors under one hour and 22 minutes from Pennsylvania University! And claimedprosecutors tim piazza surveillance video footage zeroing in onselect portions of the person who deleted footage... System as something to be used for extracting a pound of flesh why we disagree so much 2... Justin is an assistant managing editor at CBS News a judge dismissed the most charges... And killing someone which would still be involuntary manslaughter high horse and looking on... Not a defense for a crime, said via Twitter that the courtroom was silent prosecutors.